Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This doesn't affect our recommendations or editorial integrity. Learn more

Expert Picks for January 2026

Best Pool Skimmers

Leaves and debris on the surface look terrible and clog filters. We compared skimmers from manual nets to floating collectors.

Last updated: January 28, 2026
Share:
Best Overall Our top recommendation
Best Overall
Professional Heavy Duty Leaf Rake

Swimline

Professional Heavy Duty Leaf Rake

4.6 (12,345 reviews)

The pro-grade rake that makes skimming actually effective. That deep bag holds pounds of leaves without dumping back into the pool. Finally, a skimmer that's a tool, not a toy.

Size

18" x 16" x 10" deep

Frame

Aluminum

Bag

Fine mesh

Connection

Universal

Pros

  • Deep bag holds more
  • Aluminum frame
  • Standard pole attachment

Cons

  • Bag can tear
  • Need pole separately
  • Heavy when full

Head-to-Head Comparison

ProductRatingPrice Action
Professional Heavy Duty Leaf Rake
Professional Heavy Duty Leaf Rake Best
Swimline
4.6
$24 View
PoolSkim Automatic Surface Skimmer
PoolSkim Automatic Surface Skimmer
PoolSkim
4.4
$189 View
Flat Skimmer Net - Fine Mesh
Flat Skimmer Net - Fine Mesh Value
Milliard
4.5
$14 View
Heavy Duty Bag Skimmer
Heavy Duty Bag Skimmer
U.S. Pool Supply
4.3
$12 View
Premier Collection Heavy Duty Skimmer
Premier Collection Heavy Duty Skimmer
Poolmaster
4.4
$29 View

* Prices may vary. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

All Recommended Products

Best Overall
Professional Heavy Duty Leaf Rake

Swimline

Professional Heavy Duty Leaf Rake

4.6 (12,345 reviews)

The pro-grade rake that makes skimming actually effective. That deep bag holds pounds of leaves without dumping back into the pool. Finally, a skimmer that's a tool, not a toy.

Size

18" x 16" x 10" deep

Frame

Aluminum

Bag

Fine mesh

Connection

Universal

Pros

  • Deep bag holds more
  • Aluminum frame
  • Standard pole attachment

Cons

  • Bag can tear
  • Need pole separately
  • Heavy when full
Premium Pick
PoolSkim Automatic Surface Skimmer

PoolSkim

PoolSkim Automatic Surface Skimmer

4.4 (3,456 reviews)

Skimming without effort. This solar-powered device cruises your pool surface collecting bugs, leaves, and pollen automatically. Drop it in, let it work. The future of lazy pool maintenance.

Power

Solar + battery

Operation

Automatic

Pool Size

Up to 40 ft

Debris

Surface floating

Pros

  • Solar-powered
  • Automatic operation
  • Works in any pool

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Small debris only
  • Motor can fail
Best Value
Flat Skimmer Net - Fine Mesh

Milliard

Flat Skimmer Net - Fine Mesh

4.5 (8,765 reviews)

The daily skimmer for surface debris. Ultra-fine mesh catches pollen and small particles that fall through regular nets. Light enough for quick daily passes. Every pool needs a flat skimmer.

Size

18" wide

Frame

Aluminum

Mesh

Ultra-fine

Profile

Flat

Pros

  • Ultra-fine mesh catches pollen
  • Flat profile works surface
  • Lightweight aluminum

Cons

  • Shallow—no depth
  • Fine mesh clogs
  • Handle flexes
Budget Pick
Heavy Duty Bag Skimmer

U.S. Pool Supply

Heavy Duty Bag Skimmer

4.3 (15,678 reviews)

The no-nonsense skimmer that costs less than lunch. Does it collect leaves? Yes. Does it attach to your pole? Yes. Is it cheap enough to replace without guilt? Also yes. The practical choice.

Size

17" wide

Frame

Aluminum

Bag Depth

Medium

Fit

Standard poles

Pros

  • Under $15
  • Medium depth bag
  • Durable frame

Cons

  • Basic construction
  • Bag wears over time
  • Aluminum bends if forced
Premier Collection Heavy Duty Skimmer

Poolmaster

Premier Collection Heavy Duty Skimmer

4.4 (5,678 reviews)

The skimmer that survives seasons. Reinforced rim won't bend when you inevitably scoop against the wall. Extra-deep bag handles leaf dumps without overflow. Built for people who actually use their tools.

Size

18" x 13"

Bag Depth

15"

Frame

Powder-coated aluminum

Rim

Reinforced

Pros

  • Reinforced rim
  • Extra-deep bag
  • Powder-coated frame

Cons

  • Heavier than basic
  • Premium price for skimmer
  • Bag replacement needed

Buying Guide: How to Choose Pool Skimmers


How to Choose a Pool Skimmer

Skimmers come in two forms: the built-in box in your pool wall (not replaceable), and the net-on-a-pole (your daily weapon). This guide covers handheld skimmer tools—the ones you use to scoop debris before it sinks.

Skimmer Net Types

Flat Skimmers
Wide, shallow nets that glide across the water surface. Best for daily debris removal, pollen collection, and light leaves. Quick passes keep the surface clear.

Deep Bag Rakes
Nets with 8-15" deep bags for heavy debris collection. Essential for leaf season or after storms. Hold more, empty less often.

Heavy Duty/Commercial
Reinforced frames, larger dimensions, deeper bags. Built for frequent use and rough handling. Professional pool service quality.

### Frame Materials

Plastic: Cheapest, lightest, breaks first. Fine for occasional use.

Aluminum: Standard choice. Lightweight, durable, affordable. Bends if abused but lasts for seasons.

Stainless Steel: Premium durability. Won't corrode or bend. Heavier and more expensive.

### Pole Considerations

Skimmer heads need poles. Most use standard thread connections. Telescoping poles adjust from 8-16 feet for different pool sizes. Buy a pole that reaches your pool's far wall without straining.

### Mesh Types

Standard Mesh: Catches leaves, bugs, large debris. Most common, easiest to clean.

Fine Mesh: Catches pollen, small insects, fine debris. Clogs faster but removes more.

Replaceable Bag: Some skimmers have replaceable mesh bags. Useful when mesh tears or wears.

### Automatic Options

Solar-powered surface skimmers cruise autonomously collecting floating debris. Expensive ($150-300) but eliminate daily manual skimming. Work best in conjunction with, not instead of, manual skimmers.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pool Skimmers

How often should I skim my pool?

Daily during swim season, especially before debris sinks. Floating debris is easy to remove; sunken debris requires vacuuming. Morning skims catch overnight deposits. Post-storm skims prevent organic staining. More frequent skimming means less work overall.

What's the difference between skimmer baskets and skimmer nets?

Built-in skimmer baskets sit in your pool wall skimmer box, catching debris that flows in through the suction system. Skimmer nets are handheld tools for manually scooping surface debris. Both work together—nets catch what baskets miss, baskets handle continuous flow.

Why do skimmer bags tear so easily?

Scooping against pool walls, lifting heavy loads, UV degradation, and cheap mesh construction all cause tears. Minimize by scooping under debris rather than scraping, emptying before overloading, and storing out of direct sun. Budget for replacement bags—they're consumables.

Should I get a flat skimmer or deep bag rake?

Get both. Flat skimmers excel at daily surface maintenance—quick passes to remove pollen, bugs, and light debris. Deep rakes handle heavy leaf loads and storm cleanup. A flat skimmer for daily use and a deep rake for weekly/as-needed is the standard combination.

Was this guide helpful?

Why Trust Our Recommendations?

We analyze thousands of real customer reviews, compare product specifications, and curate recommendations so you can make an informed decision without the research hassle.

Curated Recommendations
Real Customer Reviews
Specs Compared
No Paid Placements